Twitter

If you haven't listened to them already, you should. IZ*ONE's latest single 'La Vie en Rose' and CLC's  'BLACK DRESS'.

The similarity of these two songs has been what CLC fans have been talking about lately. You can have a quick listen to both below.

CLC member Elkie stated earlier this year that the group would be making a supposed comeback some time between July and August, while also uploading photos of "roses" on social media. However, as we know, the comeback was delayed.

And fast forward to November 1st. CLC appear on their reality TV show, and continue dropping hints of a comeback single. A video of them performing pretty much the exact same choreography of IZ*ONE's 'La Vie en Rose' leaked online.

In the current situation, CLC fans don't seem to be too happy as there have been some netizens saying that the song was better off going to IZ*ONE from a business point of view. And the fact that CLC still haven't made their comeback only seems to aggravate them even more.

 

Read More : Tokyo Sports Criticize BTS’s Love For Their Country

guest
46 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
arianna
Guest
arianna
Dec 10, 2020 11:01 pm

izone fits better

Karyl Jamelarin
Guest
Karyl Jamelarin
Oct 10, 2020 04:55 pm

i think izone not fault because izone suit the song

Guest
Guest
Guest
Sep 12, 2020 11:22 am

who else can't really hear it.

Guest
Guest
Guest
Oct 26, 2019 05:32 am

i feel like iz*one fit's the song better but it would be nice to see CLC preform it 😀

Guest
Guest
Guest
Aug 1, 2019 12:38 am

Hah this is funny. Iz*One doesn't even have a quarter of the talent clc does.

stopthehate
Guest
stopthehate
Jun 15, 2020 06:53 pm
Reply to  Guest

thats not for you to say.. just shut up when you know nothing about iz*one.

vaffangool
Guest
vaffangool
Jun 28, 2019 04:18 am

Alot of you are confusing great songs with hit songs. Not all great songs become hits, and not all hits are even decent songs. This was no missed opportunity for CLC. La Vie en Rose is not a particularly good song, and if Cube Entertainment couldn't turn Hobgoblin into a megahit for CLC, there's not much they could have done with LVER.  The song was a hit for IZ*One because each member had many thousands of fans (including me—I stan Chaeyeon and Yena) before the group even debuted. EJ E&M and Mnet spent 4 billion won and gave them months… Read more »

LinLinIconic
Member
LinLinIconic
Apr 1, 2019 11:07 am

Ok. JYP was the original creator of the song, and he was going to originally give it to CUBE for CLC, but plans changed and he decided to give it IZ*ONE instead. Neither of the groups are at fault for this.

Guest
Guest
Guest
Aug 3, 2019 08:39 am
Reply to  LinLinIconic

That’s not what happened at all. Cube already had the song. Mnet bought the song from cube after clc were already done recording. If it wasn’t ACTUALLY CLCs song, we wouldn’t be mad.

shin eunbi
Guest
shin eunbi
Nov 27, 2019 12:18 pm
Reply to  Guest

thing is none of the group are at fault? you cant blame izone just because they performed the song instead. you can see this song doesnt even fit clc. and fit izone more. clc are now quite successful with their hit of songs so i dont think it'll be nice to blame izone or clc.

Guest
Guest
Guest
Jan 15, 2019 05:20 pm

also it's cube's fault...they never care about clc or other band in cube...they only focus on gidle just because latata went viral for a while and that they became so popular so soo...also first they disbanded beast then 4minute...just WHAT THE HELL ARE YOU DOING CUBE? im just worried that clc will disband too....I HATE YOU CUBE IF YOU DONT CARE ABOUT CLC THEN WHY DID U EVEN BOTHER TO DEBUT THEM,HUH?

Guest
Guest
Guest
Jan 15, 2019 05:15 pm

well if clc sang the song they have become more popular so i telling u this izone fans...clc is way more talented their main vocals have the strongest voice the main dancer(who is also the leader)is way more talented than the other girl groups dancers.they r also way more beautiful...besides izone just debuted...even when clc debuted they got a lot of attention from people but then poof...

nameless
Guest
nameless
Nov 27, 2019 12:24 pm
Reply to  Guest

for fuck sake. i dont care how fucking mad you are. you insult izone just because they took the song that dont fucking suit clc? are you sure bout that? if clc perform that song can you expect what will happen? la vie en rose obviously suit izone more than clc. just because they performed the song that clc HAVE finish recording doesnt mean they're at fault. firstly they didnt buy that fucking song. and they suit the song more. how are you so sure that clc are soooooo talented until izone dont deserve that song? clc IS not more… Read more »

Karyl Jamelarin
Guest
Karyl Jamelarin
Oct 10, 2020 05:01 pm
Reply to  nameless

I think your right because la vie rose fit in the izone because they to beautiful and clc is not fit in the song.Clc is talented but izone is more talented Clc is beautiful all the kpop is beautiful.Not all the kpop base on the face it base on talent

youknowimamulti
Guest
youknowimamulti
Dec 18, 2019 02:41 am
Reply to  nameless

you're such a asshole ya know that? This person was just stating their opinion and you come after them cursing and calling them a bitch. You know, I think you're wrong. One because of how rude I never know iz*one stans could be and two that clc has more talent as their training time was longer than your ultimate's groups. You can't do anything about it since clc are an old group and iz*one just debuted. Hoes mad ig. You yourself are comparing the two, and I think you're wrong a loser too for being a bitch.

Guest
Guest
Guest
Jun 25, 2019 06:35 am
Reply to  Guest

ooooook hon stop drinking and lie down. CLC is better by far, with a bomb rapper, amazing vocalists, visuals, and not to mention dance line that's better than izone, who are so bad they shouldn't even have a dance line.

Karyl Jamelarin
Guest
Karyl Jamelarin
Oct 10, 2020 05:06 pm
Reply to  Guest

Dont compare CLC to IZ*ONE because both of them had a talented members if going arguing about the song you should report it bitch

Trashystan
Guest
Trashystan
Mar 23, 2020 09:51 am
Reply to  Guest

Facts

LinLinIconic
Member
LinLinIconic
Apr 1, 2019 11:05 am
Reply to  Guest

Ok listen. I get you CLC fans are upset, but that doesn Ꞌ t give you permission to insult IZ*ONE like that...

Guest
Guest
Guest
Mar 15, 2019 09:08 am
Reply to  Guest

Sevin and Valkryie, we shouldn't compare i*zone and clc. Both groups are different with their own talents. This issue wasn't caused by clc or i*zone, but cube. Cube sold the song that might have been clc's. tbh talent has nothing to do with this...

Guest
Guest
Guest
Feb 3, 2019 05:12 am
Reply to  Guest

way more talented wow lol keep thinking that. iz*one have a wayyyy better dance line and sure the rapper from clc is better but the vocal line are on the same level. seunghee is a better main vocalist, but as a whole iz*one's vocal line is better sooo

Antieverything
Guest
Antieverything
Jan 16, 2020 09:42 am
Reply to  Guest

ur actually on something. Are your ears working? Cause last time I checked, Izone had no talent whatsoever and they all looked like they were seizing when they danced, it sounded like an injured animal was getting eaten alive when they sang, and the raps,well....should I even call them raps? They were breathless words with no flavor whatsoever. Soooooo

Guest
Guest
Guest
Dec 29, 2018 01:37 am

CUBE wyd?

Guest
Guest
Guest
Dec 28, 2018 06:05 am

It's not IZ*ONE's fault that the song went to them instead of CLC. They are both very talented groups but it was CUBE that chose to sell the song instead of giving it to CLC. But again, after all the scandals with E'dawn and Hyuna CUBE needed the money. So in the end, it's just people trying to survive the entertainment industry.

Guest
Guest
Guest
Dec 12, 2018 04:18 pm

YEAH WELL
If u guys just think that IZ*ONE HAS NO TALENT than u r WRONG.

U HAVE TO WATCH PRODUCE 48 than u can tell us if IZ*ONE HAS NO TALENT.

THEY MIGHT BE TOO PRETTY AND TO TALENTED, AND THEY ARE SO FAMOUS EVEN IF THEY ARE JUST DEBUTED, BUT I'M PRETTY SUREEE U R JUST SOSOSOSOSO JEALOUS BCS UR IDOL AREN'T MORE SUCCESSFUL THAN IZ*ONE, 'THE MOST TALENTED ONE'

antieverything
Guest
antieverything
Jan 16, 2020 09:45 am
Reply to  Guest

'THE MOST TALENTED ONE' LMAOOOOO ur funnnny. Izone suck, unlike CLC, who actually TRAINED to debut and have always been talented. Meanwhile Izone.....*cough cough* RIGGED *cough cough*

youknowimamulti
Guest
youknowimamulti
Dec 18, 2019 02:45 am
Reply to  Guest

Listen. They only made it through as they were popular trainees. Don't come blah blah blahing over here without proper reasoning. In this industry idols aren't chosen by talent but by visuals and popularity. In other words, you're wrong and we ain't jealous it's just that hoes mad

Guest
Guest
Guest
Dec 15, 2018 08:04 pm
Reply to  Guest

In all the PD101 shows, you can eliminate some of the members from the final line-up/replace them with people who didn't make it. Not everyone who makes it into the final line-up has a talent. They make it because they're either A) Popular or B) Have the visuals. And yes, I have watched all 3 Korean seasons as well as the Chinese season and Idol Producer.

OrangeRaindrop
Guest
OrangeRaindrop
Dec 10, 2018 08:44 pm

It's not because of the song that I zone became popular it's just that they have raw talent and people are giving support to the rookie band! But if click had done this song no one would have cared except click fans
!! It became popular because this band just debuted and I'm pretty sure clc's popularity is over!

Funny
Guest
Funny
Jan 16, 2020 09:49 am
Reply to  OrangeRaindrop

Just like your good judgement

Guest
Guest
Guest
Nov 30, 2018 02:01 pm

So I am NOT in any way biased towards one of these groups. I stan IZ*ONE and they are one of my favorite groups and I am also a Cheshire. People shouldn't freak out over a song being switched to a different group. Personally I think that the song fits IZ*ONE better, I think the girls are amazing in it and the concept of the song really suits them. However I am hoping for a CLC comeback soon! I don't think people should freak out over a song switch, it happnes all the time! Anyways that's just my opinon please… Read more »

Guest
Guest
Guest
Dec 21, 2018 01:57 pm
Reply to  Guest

I couldn't agree with you more. They are both amazing groups, but they have different vibes. People have a problem of overreacting to stuff in the kpop fandom. It happens else where but not to the point that there are articles being put out about it. Even if some people think CLC would have done better with the song or upset at the situation with CUBE and CLC right now, there is no excuse for people getting this offended or freaked out over it. There are ways to handle the emotional part of this and getting angry over something like… Read more »

Guest
Guest
Guest
Nov 23, 2018 07:33 am

Why people can't calm down? Just chill, it's normal in K-pop industries to give a song to another person or another group
And even some people start to hate IZ*ONE or bash some agency for something that happens soo many times in K-pop industries

Fyi, f(x) still haven't made their comeback longer than CLC ?

Guest
Guest
Guest
Dec 10, 2018 09:46 am
Reply to  Guest

But F(x) is more popular so when they comeback (if they ever do) they’ll still have f s and plus CLC has never hit their peak. They almost hit it with black dress and having a comeback right after would have probably gave them their breakthrough.

Guest
Guest
Guest
Nov 10, 2018 07:54 pm

I think CUBE wants to focus all their money on (G)I-DLE.

Guest
Guest
Guest
Jan 4, 2019 08:31 am
Reply to  Guest

I agree. And I love (G)I-DLE. But it breaks my heart for CLC.

Guest
Guest
Guest
Nov 7, 2018 01:02 am

Fxxk for CUBE ENT.......this song was very suitable CLC'S STYLE.......BECAUSE OF CUBE STUPID STRATEGY, CLC WAS LOST CHANCE TO BE TEABAK K POP FEMALE GROUP FOR THIS YEAR........FXXK CUBE........

Guest
Guest
Guest
Nov 23, 2018 07:35 am
Reply to  Guest

that's just a possibility. there's no guarantee that La Vie en Rose will be more successful if CLC sang them

Guest
Guest
Guest
Nov 6, 2018 04:56 pm

facts that izone is more better than clc..and sound so cringy when clc change a little bit lyrics in La vie en rose...that not your song so be embarrassed...lol

Guest
Guest
Guest
Jul 7, 2019 06:10 am
Reply to  Guest

no shame in stanning one of kpop's top girl groups

Guest
Guest
Guest
Jun 25, 2019 06:40 am
Reply to  Guest

ha ur the one to be embarrassed. I mean stanning IZONE . . . yikes

Guest
Guest
Guest
Feb 3, 2019 05:10 am
Reply to  Guest

ur right for the most part, but la vie en rose was NEVER clc's song. it will always belong to iz*one cuz clc only sang the demo, which is not the song. so la vie en rose is iz*one's song and will never be clc's.

Guest
Guest
Guest
Dec 29, 2018 06:28 am
Reply to  Guest

stop being a toxic fan, you're only causing fanwars. No group is "superior" to the other, both of them work hard. And CLC didn't change the lyrics, IZ*ONE did. La
Vie En Rose was originally CLC's song. Educate yourself, because the facts you're stating are all incorrect.

Guest
Guest
Guest
Dec 15, 2018 08:07 pm
Reply to  Guest

Wouldn't say there's no real talent in the group. That's pushing it. Yuri, Chaewon, Eunbi, and Nako are wonderful vocalists. Chaeyeon is the best dancer of the 12 but also a great vocalist as well. Some of the other members made it on purely because of looks which I agree with.

Minjim_kimjung
Guest
Minjim_kimjung
Dec 1, 2018 12:11 am
Reply to  Guest

Um sorry dont come up here with that shit. Izone is solely visuals, and their visuals are decent at best. there is no real talent in that group and we all know it. Produce 48 failed us there.

Guest
Guest
Guest
Nov 5, 2018 03:01 pm

uh no clc fans are upset with cube because clc was let down despite being told they were making a comeback soon, so sure to the that point of excitement that they even gave hints. it in't hate to iz*one. also not sure if this is what you meant by the saying the last video is one of clc performing bc of your diction, but no, those dancers aren't them. just the singing.